We've tried about a million different ways to do this; this time we're letting someone else handle it.
When we returned from school today, Karol found a letter taped to her door from the Paci Fairy:
Dear Karol,I am the Paci Fairy. Since you are a big girl now, I have taken your pacifier to give to new babies that need pacis. If you are a very good girl over the next few days, I will bring you a special present for being so good and going to sleep without your pacifier.Love, The Paci Fairy
Karol was a little distraught over this, but the promise of a gift made her feel a little bit better. In fact, Karol wrote back to the Paci Fairy:
Dear Paci Fairy,I am so memorized (mesmerized) with you. I would like you to bring a Rapunzel doll from Target, please.Love, Karol
Yeah, she told the Paci Fairy what to bring. That's okay. I'd buy her a friggin' pony if this thing worked!
After a bit of a rough night the first night (which Daddy heroically tended to), we're on night two and Karol went to bed and fell fast asleep with not even a peep! If this keeps up, she'll have her new doll by Tuesday!